Caleb Williams and Drake Maye shared the field Thursday night when the Chicago Bears host the New England Patriots. Both quarterbacks entered the NFL in 2024 with enormous expectations, and two years later, the debate over which franchise made the better investment is far from settled.
Former NFL safety and ESPN analyst Ryan Clark spent part of Thursday's episode of The Pivot Podcast breaking down film of both quarterbacks. What stood out wasn't necessarily who was better. It was how differently Williams and Maye can take over a football game.
Ryan Clark sees something unusual in Caleb Williams' game
Clark started with Williams, examining several throws that most quarterbacks wouldn't even consider attempting.
One came against the Atlanta Falcons, when Williams moved inside the pocket before delivering a difficult pass to tight end Colston Loveland. The throwing angle alone caught Clark's attention.
"Your body is just not supposed to be able to do that and throw this football," Clark said.
He wasn't finished.
Clark went back to another play earlier in the season, showing Williams rolling to his right before firing a pass across the field. The quarterback had to twist his body into an awkward position to deliver the football.
"This is not coached. This is also just not even okay," Clark explained.
That's what makes Williams so difficult to evaluate through traditional quarterback standards.
There are throws coaches spend years telling young quarterbacks not to attempt. Williams makes some of those same throws look routine.
Of course, there's a downside. That willingness to improvise can occasionally lead to unnecessary risks. But Chicago is learning how to take advantage of Williams' creativity rather than trying to eliminate it.
And under Ben Johnson, the Bears have built an offense that doesn't require their quarterback to rescue every possession.
Drake Maye is giving Ryan Clark something different to appreciate
When Clark turned his attention to Maye, the discussion shifted.
Rather than focusing primarily on unconventional throwing mechanics, Clark highlighted the Patriots quarterback's ability to recognize coverage, manipulate defenders and put the football where only his receivers could reach it.
On one play, Maye recognized how the coverage was developing and delivered a pass across the field that forced the cornerback to chase the receiver rather than attack the football.
Clark was impressed with the placement.
He also examined Maye's ability to find receivers downfield, noting how effectively the quarterback has been processing defensive looks.
"I love the way that he's reading the field and getting the ball out of his hands," Clark said.
But Maye isn't simply a pocket passer.
Clark also highlighted his ability to run, showing a play where the quarterback escaped a defender and picked up yardage with his legs.
That combination creates problems for Chicago, particularly given Dennis Allen's willingness to send extra pressure.
Williams and Maye could settle another chapter of their draft debate
The interesting part of Clark's breakdown is that neither quarterback needs to play like the other to be successful.
Williams can turn a broken play into a highlight with a throw that seems physically impossible. Maye can dissect a defense by identifying the right matchup and delivering the football before the coverage reacts.
Both have the athleticism to punish defenses that lose contain.
Clark never explicitly declared one quarterback better than the other. His analysis instead demonstrated why the debate is more complicated than comparing passing statistics.
For Chicago, Thursday's matchup is another opportunity for Williams to show why the Bears selected him first overall in 2024.
Maye, selected two picks later, has his own opportunity to make a statement.
Two quarterbacks from the same draft class. Two different approaches to the position.
And one nationally televised game that should give everyone plenty more to argue about.
Add us as a preferred source on Google