How much patience does Jeff Blashill deserve? It's becoming a fair question in Chicago, where the Blackhawks entered the week at 5-13-2 and appear headed toward another frustrating season.
Nobody expected a playoff run. The roster is young, and general manager Kyle Davidson has made it clear that developing talent remains the priority. But the Blackhawks have been rebuilding for years now. Eventually, fans should expect to see something resembling progress.
Davidson recently backed Blashill publicly, and Connor Bedard expressed confidence in his coach. That's all well and good, but neither endorsement changes the results.
Jeff Blashill's numbers tell a troubling story
As reported by the Chicago Tribune last week, through his first 100 games coaching Chicago, Blashill's numbers leave plenty to be desired:
- Overall record: 33-52-15
- Goals scored per game: 2.49
- Goals allowed per game: 3.46
- Expected-goals share: 42.81%
- Power-play percentage: 15.7%
- Penalty-kill percentage: 82.7%
Chicago's penalty kill has been one of the few bright spots. Otherwise, there isn't much here to suggest the Blackhawks are becoming a more competitive team.
The expected-goals percentage is particularly telling. Chicago isn't just struggling to finish scoring opportunities. Opponents are consistently creating better chances.
Some of that falls on the roster Davidson assembled. But Blashill is responsible for getting those players to execute his system, and that hasn't happened consistently.
How many embarrassing losses are too many?
Chicago's 9-2 loss to Carolina was ugly. The Blackhawks followed it with a victory over Buffalo, which offered some encouragement, before blowing a four-goal lead against Winnipeg.
It's difficult to identify meaningful improvement when performances swing that dramatically.
Young teams make mistakes. Defensemen get caught out of position, forwards miss assignments, and leads disappear. That's part of the learning process.
But those mistakes should become less frequent as the season progresses.
Davidson has acknowledged concerns about odd-man rushes and the number of quality chances Chicago allows. Assistant general manager Mark Eaton has also become more involved with the coaching staff to help address defensive development.
That raises another question. If the coaching staff already has a plan for developing these players, why does the front office need to become more involved in implementing it?
There's nothing inherently wrong with Eaton helping. Still, it's difficult to overlook the timing.
Kyle Davidson can't escape responsibility
Blashill inherited a rebuilding team, not a finished product. Davidson hired him knowing the roster would have limitations.
That makes evaluating the coach more complicated than simply looking at the standings.
Bedard has missed time, and injuries have affected the lineup. Chicago also lacks the experienced depth needed to compete consistently against stronger opponents.
Those are legitimate obstacles.
But Davidson has spent years building this roster through the draft and trades. If the players aren't developing as expected, the general manager needs to determine whether the problem is talent, coaching or his own expectations.
Keeping Blashill might be the correct decision. Doing so without demanding measurable improvement would be considerably harder to defend.
The Blackhawks need to show something
Chicago doesn't need to fire Blashill tomorrow. Another coaching change could accomplish very little with the same roster.
What the Blackhawks need is a stretch of games where defensive assignments are handled correctly, leads aren't routinely squandered and opponents aren't controlling play for extended periods.
Those aren't unreasonable expectations for a rebuilding franchise.
Blashill still has an opportunity to prove he's the right person for this job. But if the Blackhawks reach the end of another season making the same mistakes, Davidson will have a difficult time explaining why another year under the same coach is the answer.
| More Blackhawks on DaWindyCity |
