Skip to main content

Caleb Williams' MVP hopes may be slipping away for reasons beyond his control

ByChris Pownall
Nov 8, 2026; Chicago, Illinois, USA;  Chicago Bears quarterback Caleb Williams (18) drops back to pass against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers in the second half at Soldier Field.  Mandatory Credit: Matt Marton-Imagn Images
Nov 8, 2026; Chicago, Illinois, USA; Chicago Bears quarterback Caleb Williams (18) drops back to pass against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers in the second half at Soldier Field. Mandatory Credit: Matt Marton-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Caleb Williams could play some of the best football of his young career over the next two months and still find himself on the outside looking in when NFL MVP votes are counted.

That might sound unfair, but it's the reality facing the Chicago Bears quarterback. Williams has made considerable progress under Ben Johnson, earning praise from national analysts who now consider him among the NFL's top quarterbacks. Unfortunately, his MVP candidacy could be decided by something he can no longer change.

Three missed games.

During Thursday's Pro Football Talk, Mike Florio explained why Williams could be fighting a losing battle regardless of how well he performs down the stretch.

Mike Florio identifies the biggest obstacle facing Williams

"He would be one of the top MVP candidates right now if he hadn't missed those three games," Florio said.

It's a significant statement considering how much Williams has improved. However, Florio's concern goes beyond simply missing time.

Williams cannot make up the passing yards, touchdowns or victories he might have accumulated during those three games. Meanwhile, quarterbacks who remain healthy have additional opportunities to strengthen their MVP cases.

That's a disadvantage Williams has no way of eliminating.

Even if he outperforms his competition over the remaining schedule, another quarterback could finish with considerably better cumulative statistics simply because he played more games.

History isn't particularly encouraging, either. Joe Montana won MVP in 1989 despite missing three games, but such accomplishments are exceptionally rare.

Williams would need to overcome an obstacle that has stopped nearly every quarterback before him.

Williams can't control what happens elsewhere in the NFL

There's another problem with Williams' MVP candidacy that has nothing to do with his own performance.

He cannot control whether other quarterbacks struggle.

If one of the league's leading candidates continues producing impressive numbers while guiding his team toward a top playoff seed, Williams could have difficulty closing the gap.

That doesn't necessarily mean the other quarterback is playing better football. It means voters will have more games and more statistical production to evaluate.

Williams also has to overcome his four-interception performance against Tampa Bay. Unlike his missed opportunities, that outing is something he must take responsibility for.

However, one disappointing performance shouldn't erase the progress he's made throughout the season.

Ben Johnson has bigger expectations for his quarterback

While the MVP discussion makes for interesting television, Johnson appears focused on something considerably more important.

The Bears head coach recently praised Williams for recognizing defensive coverages, processing information and executing increasingly complicated offensive concepts.

Those improvements suggest Williams is becoming more than a quarterback who relies on spectacular throws.

Chris Simms echoed that sentiment during the discussion, suggesting Williams has entered the conversation among the NFL's best quarterbacks.

For Chicago, that recognition should carry more weight than any individual award.

Williams may not have enough games remaining to overcome the statistical disadvantage created by his absence. But he still controls how he performs when he's on the field.

An MVP award would be a tremendous accomplishment. Establishing himself as a quarterback capable of leading the Bears deep into the postseason would mean considerably more.

And unlike the MVP voting process, Williams still has an opportunity to influence that outcome.

Add us as a preferred source on Google